A House Cat Was Brought To A Remote Island In 1894—A Year Later A Species Was Extinct

Anyone scrolling through social media knows how “cat-obsessed” humans are. Amid the playful jests that paint our feline companions as scheming overlords, there’s a more somber streak to cat history few might know. It involves a lighthouse keeper on a remote island in New Zealand, his pregnant pet cat “Tibbles” and a small, flightless bird—the Lyall’s wren.

Lighthouses were typically situated on isolated stretches of land or islands to guide ships safely through treacherous waters or around dangerous coastlines. This strategic placement, essential for maritime navigation, meant that lighthouse keepers had to live in remote, often inaccessible locations. The solitude and monotony of this crucial role led many keepers to seek the company of pets, which provided emotional support and helped manage pests.

David Lyall was a lighthouse keeper who brought his family—his wife, at least one son and a cat—to Stephens Island in the late 19th century. The isolated island, located in New Zealand’s Cook Strait, was a closed, pristine environment, owing to a lack of human activity. Lyall, being the amateur natural history enthusiast he was, was overjoyed at the prospect of living here. He knew there would be several species to uncover and study. Unfortunately, unbeknownst to him, bringing Tibbles along for the ride would prove to be a costly mistake.

The Discovery of Stephens Island Wren

Following a handful of shipwrecks near Stephens Island in the 19th century, the New Zealand Maritime decided to erect a lighthouse there to warn seafarers of the dangerous waters around it. They entrusted an excited Lyall, an assistant lighthouse keeper at the time, with the job of keeping the wick trimmed and the fire burning bright.

Tibbles was equally excited—her feline instincts kicked in almost immediately upon her arrival. Cats, despite their domestication, retain strong predatory urges from their wild ancestors. This drive is not just about survival; hunting for cats can also be a form of play and natural behavior to keep their hunting skills honed.

On Stephens Island, Tibbles found an environment rich with opportunities to indulge these instincts. With no prior exposure to mammalian predators, the native species, including the unsuspecting Lyall’s Wren, were ill-prepared for a skilled Tibbles.

Among the prey the house cat caught was a curious bird—one that was found nowhere else and completely unknown to ornithology at the time. She would bring these birds (sometimes half-eaten and sometimes intact) back as “presents” for Lyall, who performed amateur taxidermy operations on intact samples and brought it to prominent ornithologists of the time, including one named H.H. Travers.

This bird, later named the Stephens Island wren or Lyall’s wren (Traversia lyalli), exhibited several unique characteristics. It resembled a mouse more than a bird, leading a concealed life, scurrying among logs and under rocks. Occasionally nocturnal, it had adapted well to the island’s environment with its large feet and short tail, which it used to navigate the dense underbrush rather than fly. Possibly due to abundant food or the lack of predators, the Lyall’s wren never evolved to fly. It was highly unique in this regard, being one of the few species of flightless songbirds.

This made them easy prey for Tibbles and her kittens, who were born feral in Stephens Island not long after the Lyall family moved there in 1894.

A House Cat And Its Feral Babies Toppled A Fragile Ecosystem

Before Tibbles and other predators arrived, the Lyall’s wren had adapted to a predator-free environment. Being flightless, it relied on its agility and camouflage to avoid danger. However, these adaptations did not match a predatory mammal like Tibbles and her offspring.

Cats, known for their reproductive efficiency, can have multiple litters per year with several kittens each. Tibbles may have had a litter of up to eight kittens, each capable of breeding within just four months. This rapid reproductive cycle led to a burgeoning feline population, unimpeded by natural checks and balances—the cats had no predators.

As these feral cats multiplied, so did their impact on the island’s fragile ecological balance. Each kitten grew quickly, learning to hunt and survive in the wild, honing skills that were devastatingly effective against the indigenous species like the Lyall’s wren.

Within a year of the pregnant Tibbles’ arrival, the Lyall’s wren population had plummeted. The few specimens collected and preserved by David Lyall were sent to various museums. Unfortunately, by the time the effect these cats had on the birds was fully understood, it was too late. The last known sighting of a live Lyall’s wren was in 1895, just a year after Tibbles was brought to Stephens Island.

Why Flightless Birds Suffer Most From Human-Driven Extinction

Unfortunately for Lyall’s wren, the fact that they were flightless made them an easy target for the island’s growing cat population. When predator species are introduced to an ecosystem, flightless birds tend to run a higher risk of extinction, according to a 2020 article in Science Advances.

While it is easy to blame Tibbles, we must recognize the human role in this. According to the article, flightless birds suffer more from human-caused extinction than other species. “Flightless species have undergone extinction disproportionately more often than others since the first settlements,” state the authors.

Humans set the stage for the Lyall’s wren’s extinction by introducing a non-native species to the island. Tibbles’ predatory behavior was natural and instinctive, but introducing such predators into a delicate ecosystem was an inadvertent human error.

The Lyall’s wren reminds us of our impact on the environment and the ecological consequences of introducing non-native species to isolated habitats. Today, conservation efforts worldwide aim to prevent such tragedies by protecting vulnerable species and controlling invasive predators.