35-year-old making $11,400 a week in passive income: The 3 questions I asked myself before quitting my day job

In 2018, those businesses out-earned his full-time income: He made nearly $135,600. The same thing happened the following year.

Yet despite his growing success, he stayed employed — partially because quitting felt outside of his comfort zone. “My parents’ … understanding of money was kind of imposed on me,” says Hogue, 35. “They’re savers. They couldn’t fathom not having a 9-to-5 job.”

DON’T MISS: The ultimate guide to earning passive income online

Hogue finally left his web development role in 2020: CharityEngine asked him transition into a new role, and he saw it as a sign to take the leap, he says. He left his adjunct teaching role after finishing the fall 2021 semester.

In retrospect, he could’ve done both sooner, he adds: The more time you dedicate to building passive income streams, the more money you can make.

“Life was good, but I was directly trading my time for money, and I knew it wasn’t going to get me where I wanted to be,” Hogue said during CNBC Make It’s SXSW panel in March. “By the time I left my day job, I was probably a year-plus overdue.”

Now, Hogue makes $11,400 per week in mostly passive income, according to documents reviewed by Make It. Here’s his advice on when to leave your full-time job in favor of a side hustle, and when it’s smarter to stay.

Hogue felt confident leaving his full-time jobs because he could answer “yes” to these three questions, he says:

• Does your side hustle have multiple streams of income?
• Does your side hustle make more dollars per day than your full-time job?
• Is your full-time job preventing you from growing your side hustle?

“I think you should wait and hold onto your day job for as long as you can,” says Hogue. “You will know when it’s time to leave when attending your 9-to-5 job impedes further growth of your side hustles.”

Kathy Kristof, whose blog Sidehusl has reviewed more than 500 different side gigs, offers another important question to ask yourself: Do you have the desire and financial ability to withstand bumps in the road?

“This means you need to have a certain amount of savings or another form of economic cushion — like a spouse who has benefits and enough income to float you when times are tough — to survive an extended period,” Kristof says.

For Jamie Inlow, it was a simple analysis: Building a side hustle while working full-time was tiring, and she was more passionate about one than the other.

Inlow balanced her jobs as a higher education consultant and a part-time student program coordinator in Virginia with her side hustle, a property management company called Be Still Getaways, for two and a half years.

She knew it was time to leave her other jobs and run Be Still Getaways full-time when she noticed she was starting to behave differently, and realized she could afford to pay herself a salary — in her case, $72,000 per year.

“I knew I was ready to quit my job when the demands of working full-time and working for Be Still Getaways was starting to affect my mental health and my ability to be present for my family,” Inlow told Make It last year.

Want to make extra money outside of your day job? Sign up for CNBC’s new online course How to Earn Passive Income Online to learn about common passive income streams, tips to get started and real-life success stories. CNBC Make It readers can use special discount code CNBC40 to get 40% off through August 15, 2024.

Plus, sign up for CNBC Make It’s newsletter to get tips and tricks for success at work, with money and in life.